Farmers Frustrated Over SGMA
September 29, 2017
CA Department of Water Resources Rolls Out SGMA Regulations at Meeting
By Patrick Cavanaugh, Farm News Director
The California Department of Water Resources held a recent workshop in Clovis, CA, to lay out the key components and regulations for the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, known as SGMA. It’s thought that SGMA could forever change the face of agriculture in the central San Joaquin Valley, as it will limit the amount of groundwater that can be pumped.
This entire approach of the Department of Water Resources is not sitting well with most farmers. Keith Freitas, who farms lemons on the east side of Fresno County, was at that recent workshop. “How can you call a program fair, but the stakeholders you bring to the table, before they enter the room to negotiate the deal, you cut their legs off?” Freitas asked.
“That’s basically what we have. We have a foot race here, but our legs have been cut off before the race even starts,” he said
And here's the problem - there's six deadly sins: lowering ground water levels, reducing ground water storage, increasing sea water intrusion, causing unreasonable water quality degradation, causing land subsidence and depleting surface water supplies that would have a significant and unreasonable adverse impact on beneficial uses of the surface water.
“The reason there's six deadly sins is 'cause they're all about the sins of the farmer. Not one of those sins is environmental,” Freitas said. “You think about it. We already have a subsidence and they know it, they don't blame the environmentalists for subsidence, they blame farming.”
Farmers feel that if environmental water restrictions were not in place, there would be no overdraft of ground water or subsidence.
“How do you think we're going to sustain overdraft pumping,” asked Freitas, "if they don't have surface water to recharge the ground basin?"
“My perspective is that like Westlands Water District, who decided to turn down the twin tunnels - that decision was made I think in parallel to the overall consensus of farmers saying that if it's going to be this way, if these are the rules that you're going to set and these are the game rules, then we have no choice but to fight back,” Freitas said.